Suggestions by @radhabele

Tom Hiddleston

as Arthur Parnassus in The House In the Cerulean Sea

Score: +29

Archie Renaux

as Oliver in If we were villains

Score: +1

Lucas Jade Zumann

as Henry Lavender in The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender

Score: +1

Barbara Palvin

as Meredith Dardenne in If We Were Villains

Score: -1

Dave Franco

as Sam Lloyd in The Diviners

Score: -2

Phoebe Tonkin

as Theta Knight in The Diviners

Score: -2

Michael B. Jordan

as Memphis Campbell in The Diviners

Score: -9