Suggestions by @rachbod

Adam Bakri

as Oliver in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Blythe Danner

as Older Alice Eversley in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Keira Knightley

as Kate Darling in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: 0

Sai Bennett

as June Darling in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Emma Appleton

as Young Alice Eversley in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Young Alice Eversley in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Diana Silvers

as Young Alice Eversley in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Max Irons

as Young Tom Stafford in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

Jeremy Irons

as Older Thomas Stafford in The Book of Lost and Found

Score: +1

William Hurt

as Arnold Horne in The Box in the Woods

Score: +2

Holly J. Barrett

as Patty Horne (1978) in The Box in the Woods

Score: +1

Ed Harris

as Arnold Horne in The Box in the Woods

Score: +1

Charlie Plummer

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: 0

Asa Butterfield

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: 0

Nick Robinson

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: 0

Austin Abrams

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: +3

Griffin Gluck

as Nate Fisher in The Box in the Woods

Score: 0

Connor Jessup

as Todd Cooper in The Box in the Woods

Score: 0

Emilia Jones

as Stevie Bell in The Box in the Woods

Score: -2