Suggestions by @queenofnewyork2003
961 suggestions

Harold Ramis
as Director in The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals (mid-2000s flm)

Ernie Hudson
as Bill Woodward in The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals (80s-90s movie)

Luke Perry
as Abraham "Brom" Bones in Headless (90s series)

Victoria Clark
as Mrs. Van Hopper in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Jessica Keenan Wynn
as Beatrice de Winter in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Raúl Esparza
as Jack Favell in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Hugh Panaro
as Jack Favell in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Kara Lane
as Mrs. Danvers in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Jay Armstrong Johnson
as Maxim de Winter in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Abby Mueller
as "I"/"Ich" in Rebecca the Musical (Broadway production)

Rob Houchen
as Rudolf, Crown Prince of Austria (adult) in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Damon Daunno
as Death/Der Tod in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Desi Oakley
as Elisabeth in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Judith Light
as Archduchess Sophie in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Jay Armstrong Johnson
as Franz Joseph I of Austria in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Raúl Esparza
as Luigi Lucheni in Elisabeth (Broadway production)

Kerri Green
as Stacy in Nerdy Prudes Must Die (1991 film)

Mollie Heckerling
as Debra Bannister in The Frighteners (musical adaptation)

Heidi Blickenstaff
as Magda Rees-Jones in The Frighteners (musical adaptation)

Hugh Coles
as Steve Bayliss in The Frighteners (musical adaptation)