Suggestions by @puzzlebadgerultra

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as Aaron Arnold in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Kevin Alejandro

as Rob Whitford in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Stephanie Hsu

as Rachel Lee in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Topher Grace

as Robert Rothman in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

David Cross

as Captain Richard Kinder in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Robin Lord Taylor

as Sam Fredrick in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Dylan O'Brien

as Jack Burns in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Samara Weaving

as Dr. Jerrica Stark in Creature from the Black Lagoon

Score: +2

Rob Savage

as Director in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

David Slade

as Director in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Sam Troughton

as Drew G. Brown in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Bronwyn James

as Scarlett Stuart in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

David Bruckner

as Director in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Karen Gillan

as Scarlett Stuart in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Emma Watson

as Scarlett Stuart in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +1

Jay Lycurgo

as Bruce Beeton in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +2

Spike Fearn

as Ignatius Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +2

Tom Taylor

as Ignatius Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +2

Christopher Goh

as Seamus Fu in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +2

Sally Hawkins

as Molly Brookfield in The Curse of 221B Baker Street: A Sherlock Holmes Horror Tale

Score: +2