Suggestions by @punkrockorange

Chad Michael Murray

as Jasper Wick in Eligible

Score: +2

Meghan Trainor

as Charlotte in Eligible

Score: +1

Jake Graf

as Hamilton Ryan in Eligible

Score: +3

Elizabeth Gillies

as Caroline Bingley in Eligible

Score: +2

James Marsden

as Chip Bingley in Eligible

Score: 0

Kelly Bishop

as Mrs. Bennet in Eligible

Score: 0

Edward Herrmann

as Mr. Bennet in Eligible

Score: +2

Florence Pugh

as Kitty Bennet in Eligible

Score: +1

Elizabeth Moss

as Mary Bennet in Eligible

Score: +2

Rachel McAdams

as Jane Bennet in Eligible

Score: +2

Anne Hathaway

as Elizabeth Bennet in Eligible

Score: -1

Andrew Garfield

as Fitzwilliam Darcy in Eligible

Score: +1