Suggestions by @profchocolatecake

Joe Pasquale

as Batman in The WORST Batman Movie

Score: +1

Nikocado Avocado

as Charlie in The Whale

Score: +2

Rami Malek

as Jesus Christ in Jesus of Nazareth

Score: +1

Rose Leslie

as Cleopatra in Antony and Cleopatra

Score: -2

Graham Duff

as John Waters in An Exercise in Poor Taste

Score: +1

Mark Heap

as Chris Chan in Chris Chan Biopic

Score: 0

Chris Pontius

as Danny Mills in An Exercise in Poor Taste

Score: +1

Michael Kittrell

as Divine in An Exercise in Poor Taste

Score: +1

Jonathan Banks

as Terrence Davis Sr in Temple

Score: +1

Geno Samuel

as Composer in Chris Chan Biopic

Score: +2

Stephen Fry

as Professor Albus Dumbledore in ‘Harry Potter’ TV Series On Max

Score: -6

John Cleese

as Professor Albus Dumbledore in ‘Harry Potter’ TV Series On Max

Score: -9

Taissa Farmiga

as Dianna Cowern in Temple

Score: +1

Millie Bobby Brown

as Tina Resch in The Columbus Poltergeist

Score: +1

Jessica Lange

as Barb Chandler in Chris Chan Biopic

Score: +1

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Courtney Love in Nirvana

Score: +2

Tobey Maguire

as Kurt Cobain in Nirvana

Score: -2

Robert Pattinson

as Kurt Cobain in Nirvana

Score: +2

Pam Ferris

as Barb Chandler in Chris Chan Biopic

Score: +3

Jesse Heiman

as Anthony LoGatto in Chris Chan Biopic

Score: +1