Suggestions by @princessjewels

Mae Whitman

as Mimzy in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Chelsea Frei

as Lute in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Lili Reinhart

as Charlie Morningstar in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Macaulay Culkin

as Lucifer Morningstar in Hazbin Hotel

Score: -1

Helena Dowling

as Velvette in Hazbin Hotel

Score: 0

Francia Raísa

as Vaggie in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Manny Montana

as Valentino in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Piper Mackenzie Harris

as Niffty in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Danny Pudi

as Alastor in Hazbin Hotel

Score: 0

Eliza Taylor

as Cherri Bomb in Hazbin Hotel

Score: +1

Paul Stanley

as Erik in The Phantom of the Opera (1994)

Score: -2

Sarah Brightman

as Christine Daaé in The Phantom of the Opera (1994)

Score: +1

Anne Hathaway

as Christine Daaé in The Phantom of the Opera (2014)

Score: +1

Oleg Ivenko

as Mischa Bachinski in Ride the Cyclone

Score: -1

Chris Colfer

as Noel Gruber in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Wyatt Oleff

as Ricky Potts in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Julia Lester

as Constance Blackwood in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Ocean O'Connell Rosenberg in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

David Harbour

as The Amazing Karnak in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Marion Van Cuyck

as Naru Osaka in Sailor Moon

Score: +4