Suggestions by @princessjewels

Halston Owen

as Laura in Silent Hill 2

Score: +1

Bo Mitchell

as Eddie Dombrowski in Silent Hill 2

Score: +1

Rosabell Laurenti Sellers

as Angela Orosco in Silent Hill 2

Score: +1

Rachel Brosnahan

as Mary Shepherd-Sunderland/Maria in Silent Hill 2

Score: +1

Glen Powell

as James Sunderland in Silent Hill 2

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Christine Daaé in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Jackie Evancho

as Christine Daaé in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Julian Hilliard

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan

Score: +1

Jackie Evancho

as Jane Doe/Penny Lamb in Ride the Cyclone

Score: +1

Happy Anderson

as Peter Peter in Heartless

Score: -1

Morgan Davies

as Hatta in Heartless

Score: +1

Matt Wood

as The King of Hearts in Heartless

Score: -1

Gracie Whitton

as Catherine Pinkerton in Heartless

Score: -3

Mia Sinclair Jenness

as Catherine Pinkerton in Heartless

Score: -3

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Jest in Heartless

Score: -1

Ariana Grande

as Christine Daaé in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Jonathan Bailey

as Raoul in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Josh Groban

as The Phantom of the Opera in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +2

Bryce Pinkham

as The Phantom of the Opera in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Kristin Chenoweth

as La Carlotta in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +2