Suggestions by @princeboy

Mia Sara

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things if it was actually made in the 80s

Score: +8

Jennifer Grey

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things if it was actually made in the 80s

Score: +6

Kyle Mac

as Carrie (2013) in Face Claims Sorted by Teen Movies

Score: +6

Dayle Sunohara

as Lonnie in Descendants (1985-89)

Score: +6

Rae Dawn Chong

as Justine Dancer in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +6

Anthony Kramreither Jr.

as Dexter Charming in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +5

Johnny Depp

as Dexter Charming in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +5

Heather Locklear

as Apple White in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +7

Molly Ringwald

as Poppy O'Hair in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +6

Jennifer Connelly

as Meeshell Mermaid in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +5

Betsy Russell

as Lizzie Hearts in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +6

Jennifer Rubin

as Lizzie Hearts in Ever After High (Live Action 80's)

Score: +6

Jessica Steen

as Francesca "Franci" Newell in What Character Do You Want to Jessica Steen play in the 1980's

Score: +4

Irina Skinner

as Volleyball Player in Sorting Fictional Characters by type of job.

Score: +4

Francesca "Franci" Newell

as Volleyball Player in Sorting Fictional Characters by type of job.

Score: +4

Irina Jelavić

as Irina in Sorting Characters by Name

Score: +3

Irina Skinner

as Irina in Sorting Characters by Name

Score: +2

Irina (Twilight)

as Irina in Sorting Characters by Name

Score: +2

Francesca "Franci" Newell

as Frances/Francis in Sorting Characters by Name

Score: +4

Francesca "Franci" Newell

as Jessica Steen in Which characters should actors have played in the 80’s?

Score: +5