Suggestions by @potatolover

Madeleine Stowe

as Catwoman in Batman II (1992)(story private)

Score: +1

Alec Baldwin

as Batman in Batman II (1992)(story private)

Score: +1

Joan Cusack

as Etta Candy in Wonder Woman (1991)(story private)

Score: +1

Alan Rickman

as Ares in Wonder Woman (1991)(story private)

Score: +1

Charlotte Rampling

as Queen Hippolyta in Wonder Woman (1991)(story private)

Score: +1

Kiefer Sutherland

as Steve Trevor in Wonder Woman (1991)(story private)

Score: +1

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Wonder Woman in Wonder Woman (1991)(story private)

Score: +1

Jason Bateman

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

J. T. Walsh

as Perry White in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Eva Marie Saint

as Martha Kent in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

James Garner

as Jonathan Kent in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Michael Biehn

as Metallo in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Ed Harris

as Lex Luthor in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Elizabeth Perkins

as Lois Lane in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Rob Lowe

as Superman in Superman (1990)(story private)

Score: +1

Ed Harris

as Lex Luthor in Batman (1989)(story private)

Score: +1

Treat Williams

as Harvey Dent in Batman (1989)(story private)

Score: +1

Gene Hackman

as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman (1989)(story private)

Score: +1

John Gielgud

as Alfred in Batman (1989)(story private)

Score: +1

Kathleen Turner

as Vicki Vale in Batman (1989)(story private)

Score: +1