Suggestions by @pixelwolf

Stephen Fry

as Miriel, Pastor of Vows in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Tom Blyth

as Kenneth Haight in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Huw Parmenter

as D, Beholder of Death in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Barry Keoghan

as Tarnished in Elden Ring

Score: -1

Stellan Skarsgård

as Margit, The Fell Omen in Elden Ring

Score: +6

Thomasin McKenzie

as Melina in Elden Ring

Score: +13

Jake Curran

as Godskin Apostle in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Jamie Wilkes

as Knight Bernahl in Elden Ring

Score: -1

Will Keen

as Inquisitor Ghiza in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Alexander Skarsgård

as Radagon of the Golden Order in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Tim Roth

as Smithing Master Hewg in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Ian Peck

as Godskin Noble in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Ian Gelder

as Gowry in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Justin Silverman

as Tingle in The Legend Of Zelda

Score: +1

Justin Silverman

as Melon in Food

Score: +1

Jack Farthing

as Merchant Kale in Elden Ring

Score: +3

James Norton

as Brother Corhyn in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Kiernan Shipka

as Melina in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Ruth Wilson

as Anastasia Tarnished-Eater in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Ian McElhinney

as Witch-Hunter Jerren in Elden Ring

Score: +3