Suggestions by @pikachu2342
1,762 suggestions
Millie Bobby Brown
as Lilith in Supernatural
Ryan Gosling
as Henry in Supernatural
Corey Stoll
as Samuel in Supernatural
Sofia Carson
as Ruby in Supernatural
Katherine McNamara
as Charlie in Supernatural
Mackenzie Foy
as Krissy Chambers in Supernatural
Ben Affleck
as Crowley in Supernatural
Ryan Potter
as Kevin in Supernatural
Donald Glover
as Raphael in Supernatural
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Lucifer in Supernatural
Joe Keery
as Gabriel in Supernatural
Timothée Chalamet
as Adam Milligan in Supernatural
Joaquin Phoenix
as Bobby in Supernatural
Jacob Elordi
as Jack in Supernatural
Katherine Langford
as Samantha Winchester in Supernatural
Josephine Langford
as Dana Winchester in Supernatural
Paul Rudd
as Castiel in Supernatural
Bryan Cranston
as John Winchester in Supernatural
Dacre Montgomery
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural
Charlie Heaton
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural