Suggestions by @pauldangerbuff

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Catwoman in Tim Burton's Batman III (1995)

Score: +1

Billy Dee Williams

as Two-Face in Tim Burton's Batman III (1995)

Score: +1

Marlon Wayans

as Robin in Tim Burton's Batman III (1995)

Score: +1

Michael Keaton

as Batman in Tim Burton's Batman III (1995)

Score: +2