Suggestions by @paulcoolman2

Chris Pine

as Benjamin Barry in How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days (2013)

Score: +1

Diego Calva

as Kane in Annihilation (2028)

Score: +1

Chris Pine

as Jeremiah Johnson in Jeremiah Johnson (2022)

Score: +3

James Stewart

as Philip Marlowe in The Big Sleep (1956)

Score: +2

Charlton Heston

as Philip Marlowe in The Big Sleep (1966)

Score: +2

David Krumholtz

as Commissioner Stephen Gwenn in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +2

Paul Newman

as Sam Spade in The Maltese Falcon (1961)

Score: +2

Josh O'Connor

as Officer Mitch Archer in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +1

Jack Nicholson

as Judge Holden in Blood Meridian (1985)

Score: +5

Michael Rooker

as Saul Peterson in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +2

Will Poulter

as Edmund Roberts in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +2

Pruitt Taylor Vince

as Chief Edmund Starkey in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +2

Tenoch Huerta Mejía

as Lalo Noriega in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +1

Daniela Melchior

as Doña Martinella in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +2

David Corenswet

as Nathan Heller, P.I. in Heller, Private Eye

Score: +3

Chris Evans

as Vincent Lauria in The Color of Money (2006)

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Fast Eddie" Felson in The Color of Money (2006)

Score: +2

Adèle Exarchopoulos

as Mal Cobb in Inception [2030]

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Johnny Hooker in The Sting (2023)

Score: +4

Tom Cruise

as Odysseus in The Odyssey (2016)

Score: +4