Suggestions by @paulcoolman

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Jimmy Conway in GoodFellas (2015)

Score: +4

Oscar Isaac

as Henry Hill in GoodFellas (2015)

Score: +3

Robert De Niro

as Will Graham in Manhunter (1976)

Score: +3

Harrison Ford

as Will Graham in Manhunter (1976)

Score: +4

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Kay Adams in The Godfather (2022)

Score: +1

Xolo Maridueña

as Marty McFly in Almost Cast: Back to the Future

Score: +5

Oscar Isaac

as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Denis Villeneuve's The Batman (2012)

Score: +3

Chris Pine

as Red Dead Redemption in Actors/Actresses who should join certain franchises

Score: +2

Zac Efron

as Michael Corleone in The Godfather (2022)

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Joe Burton in The Chairman's Power (2014)

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Joe Burton in The Chairman's Power (2014)

Score: +1

Raúl Juliá

as Alejandro Murrieta in The Mask of Zorro (1978)

Score: +8

Talia Shire

as Linda in Anger Management (1983)

Score: +1

Chris Evans

as Billy Costigan Jr. in Almost Cast: The Departed

Score: +1

Manny Jacinto

as Jimmy Tong in The Tuxedo (2023)

Score: 0

Jaafar Jackson

as Michael Jackson in Legacy: The Michael and Janet Jackson Story

Score: +7

Tom Cruise

as Steve Rogers in Captain America Trilogy (1991-1996)

Score: +3

Kira Kosarin

as Actors in Celebrities You’d Love to See on Hot Ones

Score: +2

Dylan O'Brien

as Paul Atreides in Almost Cast: David Lynch's Dune

Score: +5