Suggestions by @parkerc

Willie Watson

as Deputy Colt in Pastor Colt

Bill Heck

as Pastor Colt in Pastor Colt

Danny McBride

as Phil Cassidy in GTA VI

Liev Schreiber

as Wolfman in Public Domain

Hugh Jackman

as The Werewolf of London in Public Domain

Ólafur Darri Ólafsson

as Professor Challenger in Public Domain

Brian Blessed

as Professor Challenger in Public Domain

Tom Mison

as Ichabod Crane in Public Domain

Titus Welliver

as Robinson Crusoe in Public Domain

Khadijha Red Thunder

as Tiger Lily in Public Domain

Sinbad

as Sinbad the Sailor in Public Domain

Kayvan Novak

as Ali Baba in Public Domain

Manisha Koirala

as Scheherazade in Public Domain

David Letterman

as Sandman in Public Domain

Willem Dafoe

as Dr. Coppelius in Public Domain

Warwick Davis

as The Mad Hatter in Public Domain

Pierce Brosnan

as C. Auguste Dupin in Public Domain

Romain Duris

as Arsene Lupin in Public Domain

Jean Dujardin

as Arsene Lupin in Public Domain

John Malkovich

as Le Nyctalope in Public Domain