Suggestions by @paristhefilmgirl
20,169 suggestions
Lucas Scott
as Steve McQueen in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Yvonne Lime
as 2026 in Deceased Celebrities Face Claims Sorted by Year of Death
Yvonne Lime
as Lori Granger in Fear Street: Prom Queen (1955)
Elvis Presley
as Billy Nolan in Carrie (1956)
Jade Butterfield (1981)
as Barboura Morris in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Debbie Reynolds
as Alice Litten in Carrie (1956)
Nikki Chandler
as Barboura Morris in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Jade Butterfield (1981)
as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Chris83
as Best myCast User in 2026 myCast Awards
paristhefilmgirl
as Best myCast User in 2026 myCast Awards
eyricelovely
as Best myCast User in 2026 myCast Awards
Chris83
as My favourite myCastUser in Paristhefilmgirl’s Favorites
eyricelovely
as My favourite myCastUser in Paristhefilmgirl’s Favorites
Roseanne (Christine)
as Jana Lund in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Jessica Pierson
as Jana Lund in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Heather Ames
as Melissa Mckendrick in Fear Street: Prom Queen (1955)
Megan Helms (Black Christmas 2006)
as Jana Lund in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Ellie Marshall
as Rainbow Harvest in Which characters should actors have played in the 80’s?
Rob Lowe
as Reed Joyce in Fraternity Boy (Sorority Girl 1987 Genderswap)
Annette Funicello
as Young Cynthia in Bad Dreams (1958)