Suggestions by @pandarkdrew97

Mathew Lilliard

as Hobgoblin in Sam Raimi’s Uncasted Spider-Man Characters

Score: -1

Mathew Lilliard

as Roderick Kingsley in Spider-Man

Score: +1

David Harbour

as DoomGuy in Doom

Score: +1

John C. Reilly

as Bonnie in Five Nights at Freddy's (1-SL)

Score: +2

John Goodman

as Freddy Fazbear in Five Nights at Freddy's: The Movie

Score: +3

Hugh Jackman

as Jason Voorhees. in Iconic Horror Villains.

Score: +2

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Freddy Krueger. in Iconic Horror Villains.

Score: +9

Willem Dafoe

as Freddy Krueger. in Iconic Horror Villains.

Score: +6