Suggestions by @padfoots

Morgan Freeman

as Cat in Coraline

Score: +1

Sarah Paulson

as Mel Jones/Other Mother in Coraline

Score: +1

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Mr. Sergei Alexander Bobinsky/Other Bobinsky in Coraline

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Victoria Everglot in Corpse Bride

Score: +38

Johnny Depp

as Edler Gutknecht in Corpse Bride

Score: +1

Sarah Paulson

as Maudeline Everglot in Corpse Bride

Score: +15

Matt Hitt

as Remus Lupin in All The Young Dudes

Score: +20

Laura Harrier

as Emily in Corpse Bride

Score: +47

Florence Pugh

as Victoria Everglot in Corpse Bride

Score: -2

Bill Skarsgård

as Victor Van Dort in Corpse Bride

Score: +26

Mckenna Grace

as Giulia Marcovaldo in Luca

Score: +2

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Uncle Ugo in Luca

Score: +1

Marsai Martin

as Mary Macdonald (Young) in All The Young Dudes

Score: +1

Harry Lloyd

as Lucius Malfoy in All The Young Dudes

Score: +37

Mckenna Grace

as Marlene McKinnon (Young) in All The Young Dudes

Score: +11

Amanda Seyfried

as Philomena Pettigrew in All The Young Dudes

Score: +8

Charlie Rowe

as Remus Lupin (Young) in All The Young Dudes

Score: +6

Naomi Scott

as Yaz Patil in All The Young Dudes

Score: +6

Mia Wasikowska

as Livia in All The Young Dudes

Score: +3

Russell Crowe

as Fenrir Greyback in All The Young Dudes

Score: 0