Suggestions by @oswald522

James Lafferty

as Doug in The Grudge

Score: +1

Karen Gillan

as Karen Davis in The Grudge

Score: +2

Karen Gillan

as Angie Osborne in Scream 5

Score: +4

Jenna Coleman

as Clara Oswald in Doctor Who (Movie)

Score: +2

Holly Marie Combs

as Patty Halliwell in Charmed

Score: +5

Luke Hemsworth

as Dex Lawson in Charmed

Score: +3

Nina Dobrev

as Piper Halliwell in Charmed

Score: 0

David Tennant

as Jonathan Parker in Bedlam

Score: +1

Mandip Gill

as Jazmine in Bedlam

Score: +2

Warren Brown

as Eddie in Bedlam

Score: +1

Ashley Madekwe

as Molly in Bedlam

Score: +1

Hugo Speer

as Warren in Bedlam

Score: +1

Charlotte Salt

as Kate in Bedlam

Score: +1

Will Young

as Ryan in Bedlam

Score: +1

Karl Davies

as Ollie Walker in Bedlam

Score: +1

Rita Simons

as Jessica Parker in Bedlam

Score: +1

Jenna Coleman

as Zoe Dawson in Bedlam

Score: +1

Nikesh Patel

as Dan in Bedlam

Score: +1

Jack Roth

as Max in Bedlam

Score: +1

Gemma Chan

as Keira in Bedlam

Score: +1