Suggestions by @officialjaimehorn

Michael McKean

as Fred Thompson in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Sean Astin

as Duncan Hunter Sr. in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

James Nesbitt

as Mike Huckabee in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Jason Alexander

as Rudy Giuliani in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Quentin Tarantino

as Jim Gilmore in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Ian McKellen

as Ron Paul in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Ty Burrell

as Mitt Romney in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Steve Martin

as John McCain in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Kevin Kilner

as Evan Bayh in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Eric Stonestreet

as Tom Vilsack in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Peter Gallagher

as Chris Dodd in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Matthew Modine

as Joe Biden in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

George López

as Bill Richardson in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Ralph Macchio

as Dennis Kucinich in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Karl Urban

as John Edwards in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Bill Nighy

as Mike Gravel in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

Emma Thompson

as Hillary Rodham Clinton in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +1

John Macmillan

as Barack Obama in 2008 U.S presidential election

Score: +2

Melissa McCarthy

as Granny Goodness in Casting the DCU's Legion of Doom!

Score: +2

Kathy Bates

as Granny Goodness in Casting the DCU's Legion of Doom!

Score: +2