Suggestions by @notamirrorball

Amita Suman

as Madrid in To Kill a Kingdom

Score: +2

Charlie Bushnell

as Elian in To Kill a Kingdom

Score: 0

Alessio Farinella

as Percy Jackson in Percy Jackson Disney+ Live Action Show

Score: -13

Aidan Gallagher

as Shade Barrow in Red Queen

Score: -9

Timothée Chalamet

as Maven Calore in Red Queen

Score: +8

Millie Bobby Brown

as Wendy Everly in Switched

Score: 0

Jonathan Daviss

as Mercutio in Romeo and Juliet

Score: +2

Ralph Macchio

as Lord Capulet in Romeo and Juliet

Score: 0

Rob Lowe

as Lord Montague in Romeo and Juliet

Score: 0

Benjamin Wadsworth

as Romeo in Romeo and Juliet

Score: 0

Anne Hathaway

as Elora Dahl in Switched

Score: 0

Idina Menzel

as Elora Dahl in Switched

Score: 0

Sam Claflin

as Loki in Switched

Score: 0