Suggestions by @niwko

Eric Stoltz

as Jonathan Byers in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +1

Joaquin Phoenix

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +3

Molly Ringwald

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: 0

Uma Thurman

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +1

Jennifer Connelly

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +8

Brooke Shields

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +10

Laura Dern

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +1

Kerri Green

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +2

Lea Thompson

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +1

Helen Slater

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: -1

Mia Sara

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +10

Winona Ryder

as Jane "Ives" Hopper in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +4

Heather Graham

as Maxine Mayfield in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +2

Jay Underwood

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: -1

Kirk Cameron

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: -2

Corey Feldman

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +9

Shavar Ross

as Lucas Sinclair in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +3

Matthew Broderick

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +5

Charlie Sheen

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +2

Will Byers

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (80s)

Score: +1