Suggestions by @nitrogencake
4,121 suggestions
Tom Felton
as Castor Oyl in Popeye
Billy Magnussen
as Harold Hamgravy in Popeye
Robert Eggers
as Director in Popeye
Nathan Fielder
as Eugene the Jeep in Popeye
David Krumholtz
as J. Wellington Wimpy in Popeye
Udo Kier
as Poopdeck Pappy in Popeye
Colin Farrell
as Bluto in Popeye
Cristin Milioti
as Olive Oyl in Popeye
Adam Driver
as Popeye in Popeye
Ian Curtis
as Cillian Murphy in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted
Jack Benny
as Albert Brooks in Comedic influences
Ed Harris
as Oddly Different Looking Carmine Falcone in The Penguin (2004)
Spoiler
as Oddly Different Looking Carmine Falcone in The Penguin (2004)
Phylicia Rashād
as Eve Karlo in The Penguin (2004)
Dante Basco
as Victor Aguilar in The Penguin (2004)
Nathan Fielder
as Rick Moranis in Almost Cast Counterparts: Joel Schumacher's Riddler
Justice Smith
as Marlon Wayans in Almost Cast Counterparts: Joel Schumacher's Riddler
Bo Burnham
as Jim "Anti-Vaxer / Constant On-Set Nuisance" Carrey in Almost Cast Counterparts: Joel Schumacher's Riddler
Bill Hader
as Robin Williams in Almost Cast Counterparts: Joel Schumacher's Riddler
Tim McGraw
as Micky Dolenz in Almost Cast Counterparts: Joel Schumacher's Riddler