Suggestions by @nikkih

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: -2

Sam Reid

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +4

Alexander Skarsgård

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Robert Pattinson

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Tom Hiddleston

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +3

Alex Pettyfer

as Ashley Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Kate Mara

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Nina Dobrev

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +3

Emmy Rossum

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Jennifer Lawrence

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Carey Mulligan

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +3

Emma Watson

as Melanie Hamilton Wilkes in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +1

Gerard Butler

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: 0

Jared Padalecki

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: -3

Jeremy Renner

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: -1

Christian Bale

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +1

Robert Downey Jr.

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: -1

Henry Cavill

as Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind Remake

Score: +3