Suggestions by @nikivezaj

Daniel Brühl

as Baron Zemo in Thunderbolts

Score: +2

Sterling K. Brown

as Norrin Radd in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: 0

Taron Egerton

as Wolverine in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Marc Spector in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Issa Rae

as Jessica Drew in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: -2

Tye Sheridan

as Scott Summers in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +1

Norman Reedus

as Ghost Rider in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +4

Dominique Thorne

as Ironheart in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Mahershala Ali

as Blade in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Dakota Johnson

as Julia Carpenter in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: -1

Sebastian Stan

as Bucky Barnes in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +2

Anthony Mackie

as Sam Wilson in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Don Cheadle

as James Rhodes in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Mark Ruffalo

as Bruce Banner in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +5

RJ Cyler

as Miles Morales in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: 0

Patrick Stewart

as Professor X in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Beyonder in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +1

Andy Serkis

as Galactus in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: 0

Jeremy Irons

as Magneto in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3

Paul Rudd

as Scott Lang in Avengers Secret Wars

Score: +3