Suggestions by @nerdsquidssafehouse

David Firth

as M'ling in The Island Of Doctor Moreau

Mark Hamill

as Hyena Swine in The Island Of Doctor Moreau

Willem Dafoe

as The Sayer of the law in The Island Of Doctor Moreau

Anthony Hopkins

as Dr Moreau in The Island Of Doctor Moreau

Karl Urban

as Montgomery in The Island Of Doctor Moreau

Oscar Isaac

as Edward Prendick in The Island Of Doctor Moreau