Suggestions by @nathavert3000

Iain Glen

as Lord Elrond in The Lord Of The Rings (TV Series)

Score: +1

Ralph Ineson

as Aragorn in The Lord Of The Rings (TV Series)

Score: -4

Jim Broadbent

as Bilbo Baggins in The Lord Of The Rings (TV Series)

Score: +3

Sean Connery

as Gandalf The Grey in The Lord Of The Rings (TV Series)

Score: -3

Daniel Radcliffe

as Frodo Baggins in The Lord Of The Rings (TV Series)

Score: +5

Peter Dinklage

as Dwalin in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: 0

Iain Glen

as Lord Elrond in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: 0

Rory McCann

as Bard in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: 0

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Bard in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Sharlto Copley

as Gollum in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Lord Elrond in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

David Bowie

as Smaug in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: -1

Mark Addy

as Balin in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Conor McGregor

as Dwalin in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: 0

Harvey Keitel

as Thorin ”Oakenshield” in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Sean Connery

as Gandalf The Grey in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Jim Broadbent

as Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit or There And Back Again (Tolkien’s Vision)

Score: +1

Rami Malek

as Finn in Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2025)

Score: +1

Will Arnett

as Captain Falcon in Super Smash Bros Brawl

Score: +1

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Link in Super Smash Bros Brawl

Score: 0