Suggestions by @natedawwg

John Travolta

as Josh Baskin in Big (1988) Alternate cast

Score: +1

Jeff Bridges

as Josh Baskin in Big (1988) Alternate cast

Score: +1

Dennis Quaid

as Josh Baskin in Big (1988) Alternate cast

Score: +1

Kevin Costner

as Josh Baskin in Big (1988) Alternate cast

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Josh Baskin in Big (1988) Alternate cast

Score: +1

Malcolm McDowell

as Pennywise the Clown in It (1990) alternate cast

Score: +2

Roddy McDowall

as Pennywise the Clown in It (1990) alternate cast

Score: +2

Alice Cooper

as Pennywise the Clown in It (1990) alternate cast

Score: +2

Christopher McDonald

as Neil Miller in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +3

John Ritter

as Neil Miller in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +1

Bradley Whitford

as Neil Miller in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +3

Stanley Tucci

as Neil Miller in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +2

Jeff Daniels

as Neil Miller in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +3

Harrison Ford

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: -1

Michael Keaton

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +4

John Travolta

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: -1

Kurt Russell

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +4

John Ritter

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +4

Mel Gibson

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +1

Tom Hanks

as Scott Calvin / Santa Claus in The Santa Clause alternate cast

Score: +2