Suggestions by @n_harder

Olga Kurylenko

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +2

Adria Arjona

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +1

Aomi Muyock

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +2

Golshifteh Farahani

as Circe in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +2

Adrianne Palicki

as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2006)

Score: 0

Adrianne Palicki

as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2006)

Score: -1

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Aqaman in Batman vs Superman (1996)

Score: +3

Linda Fiorentino

as Lois Lane in Batman vs Superman (1996)

Score: +3

Koyuki

as Doctor Poison in Wolfgang Peterson Batman vs Superman (2004)

Score: +3

Takako Fuji

as Doctor Poison in Wolfgang Peterson Batman vs Superman (2004)

Score: +2

Kelly Hu

as Doctor Poison in Wolfgang Peterson Batman vs Superman (2004)

Score: +4

Monica Bellucci

as Wonder Woman in Wolfgang Peterson Batman vs Superman (2004)

Score: +3

María Valverde

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +1

Kate Siegel

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +3

Joanna Fyllidou

as Hippolyta in Madeline Miller's Circe

Score: +3

Monica Bellucci

as Circe in Greek Mythology

Score: +1

Madonna

as Circe in Greek Mythology

Score: +2

Anya Chalotra

as Circe in Wonder Woman 4: War of the Gods

Score: +2

The Thinker (DC)

as Clifford DeVoe in Wonder Woman 4: War of the Gods

Score: 0

Alia Bhatt

as Zatanna in Wonder Woman 4: War of the Gods

Score: +1