Suggestions by @mylesmccormick1

Danny DeVito

as Papa Elf in Elf (2023)

Score: 0

Kurt Russell

as Santa Claus in Elf (2023)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Dr. Ben Leonardo in Elf (2023)

Score: +1

Burl Ives

as Leon The Snowman in Elf (2023)

Score: +3

Jim Belushi

as Mall Santa in Elf (2023)

Score: +2

Wanda Sykes

as Gimbel's Manager in Elf (2023)

Score: +1

Steve Martin

as Donkey in Shrek Live Action (2024)

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Walter Hobbs in Elf (2023)

Score: -1

Tobey Maguire

as Jamie Langston in Jingle All The Way 3: The Return Of Turbo Man (2025)

Score: 0

Jim Carrey

as Buddy Hobbs in Elf (2023)

Score: 0

Chris Farley

as The Cat in The Hat in The Cat In The Hat illumination Entertainment Version (2024)

Score: 0

Chris Farley

as Maurice Tillet in Shrek Live Action (2024)

Score: +1