Suggestions by @my2bit2cents

ASAP Rocky

as D-Ice in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Joey King

as Maria in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: 0

Justin Long

as Johnny Sindacco in Grand Theft Auto San Andreas

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Kent Paul in Grand Theft Auto San Andreas

Score: 0

Joey Bada$$

as Carl “CJ” Johnson in Grand Theft Auto San Andreas

Score: +2

Louis C.K.

as Curly Bob in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Alfonso Herrera

as Miguel in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Nick Offerman

as One-Armed Phil in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Michael Madsen

as Ray Machowski in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Dylan O'Brien

as Luigi Goterelli in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: -1

Sadie Sink

as Misty in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Rhys Coiro

as Luigi Goterelli in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: -1

Julia Fox

as Maria in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +2

Willa Holland

as Maria in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: -2

Kaya Scodelario

as Maria in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: -2

Kid Cudi

as 8-Ball in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Jordan Peele

as Producer in Grand Theft Auto III (2001)

Score: +1

Steven Yeun

as Kenji in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Claude in Grand Theft Auto 3

Score: +7

Cristin Milioti

as Maria in Grand Theft Auto III

Score: -2