Suggestions by @mrtenebris

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Meg in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: +1

Mila Kunis

as Carlotta in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: +1

Jane Lynch

as Madame Giry in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: +1

Val Kilmer

as Raoul de Chagny in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: -1

Liz Callaway

as Christine Daae in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: +2

Kristen Dunst

as Christine Daae in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: -1

Meg Ryan

as Christine Daae in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: -2

Antonio Banderas

as Erik in The Phantom of the Opera (1995)

Score: +3

Matthew McConaughey

as Harvey Dent in Batman: A Flip of Chance

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as James Moriarty in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +2

Tom Holland

as Tyler in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Nathaniel Ment in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Eddie Redmayne

as Elias Kington in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Brendan Fraser

as Inspector Trousseau in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Michael Green

as Writer in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Kenneth Branagh

as Director in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as The Deceased Maiden in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +2

Paul Rudd

as Mycroft Holmes in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Mycroft Holmes in Sherlock Holmes: The Beginning

Score: +1