Suggestions by @mrmovie

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Princess Peach in VGCU: SUPER MARIO

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Luigi in VGCU: SUPER MARIO

Score: +1

Keegan-Michael Key

as Mario in VGCU: SUPER MARIO

Score: +1

F. Murray Abraham

as Hades in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Jake Johnson

as Zeus in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Joe Lo Truglio

as Eggplant Wizard in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Jake Eberle

as Hades in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: -1

Londyn Silzer

as Viridi in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Jason Spisak

as Orcos in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Natalie Dormer

as Medusa in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Paula Patton

as Palutena in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Jace Norman

as Pit/Dark Pit in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: +1

Raphael Alejandro

as Pit/Dark Pit in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: -1

Will Buie Jr.

as Pit/Dark Pit in VGCU: KID ICARUS

Score: -1

Isis Hainsworth

as Lenne in VGCU: FINAL FANTASY X

Score: +1

Anna Cathcart

as Paine in VGCU: FINAL FANTASY X

Score: +1

Gudmundur Thorvaldsson

as Barthello in VGCU: FINAL FANTASY X

Score: +1

Jon Bass

as Isaaru in VGCU: FINAL FANTASY X

Score: +1