Suggestions by @moviedoc
1,287 suggestions
Holt McCallany
as Arnold Flass in Batman: Year One
Score: +2
Bobby Cannavale
as Carmine Falcone in Batman: Year One
Score: 0
Timothy Dalton
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Year One
Score: +1
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Count Dracula in Universal Monsters
Score: +2
Joe Keery
as Erik the Phantom in Universal Monsters
Score: +2
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
as Earl Bassett in Tremors
Score: +2
Michael Biehn
as Green Arrow in The Dark Knight Returns
Score: +1
Morena Baccarin
as Catwoman in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: -1
Timothy Dalton
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Chazz Palminteri
as Salvatore Maroni in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Dina Meyer
as Gilda Dent in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Ron Perlman
as Solomon Grundy in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
John Carroll Lynch
as Calendar Man in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Jon Hamm
as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Anson Mount
as Batman in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: -1
Anson Mount
as Batman in Batman The Long Halloween(story removed)
Score: 0
Vincent D'Onofrio
as Solomon Grundy (or "The Reanimated Corpse of One Solomon J Grundy") in Tim Burton’s Justice League (1990s)
Score: +2
Guy Pearce
as Captain Cold in Tim Burton’s Justice League (1990s)
Score: +2
John Malkovich
as Lex Luthor in Tim Burton’s Justice League (1990s)
Score: 0
Brendan Fraser
as CLARK KENT/SUPERMAN in Tim Burton’s Justice League (1990s)
Score: +1