Suggestions by @monty

Robin/Dick Grayson (Titans)

as Hottest Male Characters in The Most Attractive and Unattractive Characters in Fiction

Karen David

as Tahani in The Good Place: The Musical

Jonathan Groff

as Josh Wilson in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Chord Overstreet

as Nathaniel Plimpton III in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Mallory Jansen

as Valencia Perez in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Timothy Omundson

as Darryl Whitefeather in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Aaron Tveit

as Greg Serrano in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Manny Jacinto

as Josh Chan in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

John Clarence Stewart

as Chidi in The Good Place: The Musical

Jane Levy

as Eleanor in The Good Place: The Musical

Vincent Rodriguez III

as Jason in The Good Place: The Musical

Cecily Strong

as Janet in The Good Place: The Musical

Danay García

as Rosa Rodriguez in Dead of Winter

John Carroll Lynch

as James Meyers in Dead of Winter

Tommy Martinez

as Alfonso Ortega in Dead of Winter

Rubén Blades

as Daniel Smith in Dead of Winter

Scott Wilson

as Father Fitzpatrick in Dead of Winter

Michael Cudlitz

as Aticus Sanders in Dead of Winter

Steve Buscemi

as Gray Beard in Dead of Winter

Salma Hayek Pinault

as Ashley Ross in Dead of Winter