Suggestions by @mockinjay2007

Father Maxi

as Pastor Jerome in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Sharon Marsh

as Kim Rye in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Randy Marsh

as Nick Rye in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Heidi Turner

as Faith Seed in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Eric Cartman

as Joseph Seed in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Wendy Testaburger

as Deputy Hudson in South Cry 5

Score: +1

StanMarsh

as Deputy Pratt in South Cry 5

Score: +1

Kenny McCormick

as Marshall Burke in South Cry 5

Score: +1

KyleBroflovski

as Sheriff Whitehorse in South Cry 5

Score: +1