Suggestions by @missywinchester24
444 suggestions

Matthew Davis
as Alaric Crawford in Buffy the Vampire Slayer: New Beginnings

Eliza Dushku
as Marissa in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Meg Donnelly
as Buffy Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer: New Beginnings

Grant Gustin
as Christopher Perry Halliwell in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Stephen Amell
as Wyatt Matthew Halliwell in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Tyler Posey
as Tyler Chase in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Matthew Daddario
as Daniel Simpson in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Dominic Sherwood
as Jacob Phillips in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Jason Behr
as Eric Cromwell in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Katie McGrath
as Athena Beauchamp in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Phoebe Tonkin
as Molly Summers in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Jordan Calloway
as Michael Morris in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Jordan Fisher
as Michael Morris in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Jordan Calloway
as Michael Morris in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Charles Shaughnessy
as Rupert Giles in Buffy the Vampire Slayer: New Beginnings

Donald Sutherland
as Rupert Giles in Buffy the Vampire Slayer: New Beginnings

Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Dr. Greenbaum in Cruel Intentions (2019)

Cole Sprouse
as Court Reynolds in Cruel Intentions (2019)

Evan Hofer
as Sebastian Valmont in Cruel Intentions (2019)

Chris Colfer
as Blaine Tuttle in Cruel Intentions (2019)