Suggestions by @missywinchester24

Misha Collins

as Griffin Benson in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Rob Benedict

as Owen Stevens in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Katie McGrath

as Athena Beauchamp in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Jenna Dewan

as Raina Niolae in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Phoebe Tonkin

as Samantha Melinda Halliwell in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Killian Gardiner in The Witches of East End

Score: +2

Milo Ventimiglia

as Bran Gardiner in The Witches of East End

Score: 0

Ian Somerhalder

as Frederick Beauchamp in The Witches of East End

Score: +1

Danielle Rose Russell

as Freya Beauchamp in The Witches of East End

Score: -1

Danielle Panabaker

as Freya Beauchamp in The Witches of East End

Score: -1

Candice King

as Ingrid Beauchamp in The Witches of East End

Score: +1

Mädchen Amick

as Joanna Beauchamp in The Witches of East End

Score: +2

Kyle Schmid

as LESTAT DE LIONCOURT in Interview with the Vampire Tv series

Score: -4

Tessa Thompson

as Bonnie Bennett in Casting MCU actors in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +3

Kat Dennings

as Katherine Pierce in Casting MCU actors in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +3

Kirsten Storms

as Carmen Mikaelson in The Story of the Mikaelson Heretic Sisters

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Dakota Mikaelson in The Story of the Mikaelson Heretic Sisters

Score: +1

Alexander Calvert

as Henrik Mikaelson/Stiles Stilinski in The Story of the Mikaelson Heretic Sisters

Score: +1

Avery Kristen Pohl

as Parker Halliwell in Charmed Legacy

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Chris Halliwell in Charmed Legacy

Score: +1