Suggestions by @mishafitt

Jim Sturgess

as Toby in The Exclusives

Score: +1

Sammi Hanratty

as Brielle in Tease

Score: -1

Katya Martín

as Sara in Tease

Score: -1

Hayley Law

as Seneca in The Amateurs

Score: -3

Annie Q. Riegel

as Madison in The Amateurs

Score: -1

Cassidy Gifford

as Mirren in We Were Liars

Score: -21

Danika Yarosh

as Aerin in The Amateurs

Score: -5

Lili Reinhart

as Aerin in The Amateurs

Score: -2

Logan Browning

as Seneca in The Amateurs

Score: -2

Eliana Jones

as Brielle in Tease

Score: +1

Ellie Bamber

as Emma in Tease

Score: +1

Madeline Carroll

as Sara in Tease

Score: -1

Liana Liberato

as Sara in Tease

Score: +3

Keeley Hawes

as Isla in Last Seen

Score: -1

Miranda Raison

as Sarah in Last Seen

Score: 0

Lucy Punch

as Sarah in Last Seen

Score: -1

Jamie Flatters

as Jacob in Last Seen

Score: +2

Ioan Gruffudd

as Nick in Last Seen

Score: 0

Joanne Froggatt

as Sarah in Last Seen

Score: -1

Ella Purnell

as Flo in The Visitors

Score: +1