Suggestions by @mishafitt

Sarah Grey

as Aphrodite LaFont in House Of Night Series

Score: -2

Brandon Baker

as Kelci "Saff" Saffery in Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem and Madness

Score: +5

Ivy Watson

as Natalie Luca in The Selection Series

Score: -3

Samantha Boscarino

as Kriss in The Selection Series

Score: -32

Florence Pugh

as Astrid Donal in The Bright Young Things Series

Score: +2

Amanda Zhou

as Elise Whisks in The Selection Series

Score: -8

Kristine Froseth

as Erin Bates in House Of Night Series

Score: -3

Kristine Froseth

as Lucy in The Selection Series

Score: -12

Kristine Froseth

as Marcie in Hush, Hush Series

Score: +5

Blu Hunt

as Zoey Redbird in House Of Night Series

Score: -3

Alysia Reiner

as Dona Oliver in Impostors series

Score: +1

Aria Shahghasemi

as Col in Impostors series

Score: 0

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Sarafine in Beautiful Creatures

Score: 0

Abigail Cowen

as Eris Dodd-Radson in The Thousandth Floor Series

Score: +13

Luke Pasqualino

as Jake in The Good Twin

Score: 0

Neve Campbell

as Lauren in The Good Twin

Score: +2

Sam Page

as Ben in The Good Twin

Score: +3

Gabriella Wilde

as Charly in The Good Twin

Score: +3

Gabriella Wilde

as Mallory in The Good Twin

Score: +2

Miya Cech

as Claudia Kishi in Baby-Sitters Club

Score: +7