Suggestions by @milesyeargain

Nicole Kidman

as Mera in Aquaman: King of Atlantis (1993)

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Ocean Master in Aquaman: King of Atlantis (1993)

Score: +1

Keith David

as Black Manta in Aquaman: King of Atlantis (1993)

Score: +1

Kevin Costner

as Aquaman in Aquaman: King of Atlantis (1993)

Score: +1

Kevin Costner

as Aquaman in Aquaman 1990s

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves (Batman)

as Batman in Nightwing: Protector of Blood Haven (2011)

Score: +1

Batgirl (Emma Stone)

as Batgirl in Nightwing: Protector of Blood Haven (2011)

Score: +1

Stephen Lang (Deathstroke)

as Deathstroke in Nightwing: Protector of Blood Haven (2011)

Score: +1

James Caan

as Tony Zucco in Nightwing: Protector of Blood Haven (2011)

Score: +1

Carter Jenkins

as Nightwing in Nightwing: Protector of Blood Haven (2011)

Score: +1

Robert Patrick

as Detective Quinton Lance in Green Arrow: Quiver’s Edge (2011)

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Speedy in Green Arrow: Quiver’s Edge (2011)

Score: +1

Young Zoe Saldana

as Black Canary in Green Arrow: Quiver’s Edge (2011)

Score: +1

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Merlyn in Green Arrow: Quiver’s Edge (2011)

Score: +1

Charlie Hunnam (Green Arrow)

as Green Arrow in Green Arrow: Quiver’s Edge (2011)

Score: +1

Michelle Rodriguez

as Renee Montoya in Batman: Two Sides of Fear (2011)

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner Jim Gordon in Batman: Two Sides of Fear (2011)

Score: +1

John Cleese

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Two Sides of Fear (2011)

Score: +1

Batgirl (Emma Stone)

as Batgirl in Batman: Two Sides of Fear (2011)

Score: +1

Carter Jenkins

as Robin in Batman: Two Sides of Fear (2011)

Score: +1