Suggestions by @mikaelsun

Ian Somerhalder

as Edward in Fairytale

Score: +1

David Chocarro

as Eugene Fitzherbert in Tangled (Live Action)

Score: -31

Tom Cruise

as Silas in Fairytale

Score: +1

Jackson Rathbone

as Harold in Fairytale

Score: +1

Holland Roden

as Freya in Fairytale

Score: +1

Ashley Greene

as Ava in Fairytale

Score: +1

Thomas Doherty

as Edward in Fairytale

Score: +1

Kaia Gerber

as Vanessa in Fairytale

Score: 0

Kaya Gerber

as Vanessa in Fairytale

Score: +2

Amy Adams

as Clarice in Fairytale

Score: +1

Crystal Reed

as Grace in Crave

Score: -24