Suggestions by @mihaialex

Brianne Tju

as Emily in Until Dawn

Brec Bassinger

as Jessica in Until Dawn

Imani Lewis

as Jessica in Until Dawn

Julia Rehwald

as Emily in Until Dawn

Emily Lind

as Jessica in Until Dawn

Whitney Peak

as Ashley in Until Dawn

Saylor Curda

as Ashley in Until Dawn

Derek Luh

as Mike in Until Dawn

Gavin Leatherwood

as Mike in Until Dawn

Lonnie Chavis

as Matt in Until Dawn

Ayo Edebiri

as Sam in Until Dawn

Amber Midthunder

as Sam in Until Dawn

Amanda stenburg

as Sam in Until Dawn

Taissa Farmiga

as Ashley in Until Dawn

Jenna Warren

as Jessica in Until Dawn

Zack Morris

as Matt in Until Dawn

Jonathan Daviss

as Matt in Until Dawn

Archie Renaux

as Josh in Until Dawn

David Iacono

as Josh in Until Dawn

Matthew Daddario

as Mike in Until Dawn