Suggestions by @michelledonalson

Elijah Kelley

as Scarecrow in The Wiz LIVE

Score: +1

Shanice Williams

as Dorothy in The Wiz LIVE

Score: +1

Kelli O'Hara

as Mrs Darling in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Jake Lucas

as John Darling in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Alanna Saunders

as Tiger Lily in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Taylor Louderman

as Wendy Darling in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

John Allyn

as Micheal Darling in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +2

Minnie Driver

as Narrator/Adult Wendy in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Mr Smee/Mr Darling in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +2

Christopher Walken

as Captain Hook in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Allison Williams

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan LIVE

Score: +1

Kristine Nielsen

as Frau Schmidt in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Elena Shaddow

as Sister Sophia in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Christiane Noll

as Sister Margaretta in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Jessica Molaskey

as Sister Berthe in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Joe West

as Kurt von Trapp in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Joe West

as Kurt von Trapp in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Ella Watts-Gorman

as Louisa von Trapp in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Grace Rundhaug

as Marta von Trapp in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1

Michael Nigro

as Friedrich von Trapp in The Sound of Music LIVE

Score: +1