Suggestions by @michaelzilla

Shaquille O'Neal

as Ignited Golden Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Jack Davenport

as Tortured Device in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +2

Carl Weathers

as Tortured Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Chris Brown

as Chuck E. Cheese in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +2

Javier Bardem

as Nightmare Fredbear in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Daveed Diggs

as Fatz Geronimo in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: 0

Chris Pine

as Frankburt in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Dave Franco

as Ignited Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Katherine McNamara

as Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as Vigo in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +2

Jonathan Majors

as Withered Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Nightmare Springtrap in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Ignited Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Anika Noni Rose

as Happy Frog in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Frankburt in The Return to Freddy's

Score: +1

Kathryn Newton

as Circus Baby in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Glamrock Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Angela Bassett

as Roxanne Wolf in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Paul Rudd

as Glamrock Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1