Suggestions by @micahmadera

Chris Hemsworth

as Cap in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +2

Liam Hemsworth

as Cap in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: 0

Woody Harrelson

as Clyde in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +2

Dafne Keen

as Minnow in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +2

Karen Fukuhara

as Aimee in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +6

Chloe Bennet

as Aimee in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +3

Natasha Liu Bordizzo

as Aimee in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Joel in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +3

Josh Hutcherson

as Joel in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +4

Logan Lerman

as Joel in Love and Monsters (Alternate Cast)

Score: +5

Mackenzie Crook

as Gríma Wormtongue in The Lord of the Rings (2021-2023)

Score: +2

Paul Rudd

as Luigi in The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2013)

Score: +2

Seth Rogen

as Wreck-It Ralph in Wreck-It Ralph (2022)

Score: +1

Brian Gleeson

as Alastor Moody in The Marauders

Score: +1

Stanislav Yanevski

as Piotr Rasputin in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +4

Matt Damon

as Scott Summers in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +3

Charlize Theron

as Dark Phoenix in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +4

Angelina Jolie

as Dark Phoenix in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +3

Anne Hathaway

as Marie D'Ancanto in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +4

Natalie Portman

as Katherine Pride in X-Men III: The Dark Phoenix (2006)

Score: +2