Suggestions by @metropolis_knight

Christoph Waltz

as Doctor Fate in DC Wonder Woman: The World War II

Score: +2

Elisabeth Moss

as Etta Candy in DC Wonder Woman: The World War II

Score: +2

Gemma Arterton

as Wonder Woman in DC Wonder Woman: The World War II

Score: +2

Ralph Fiennes

as Alfred Pennyworth in DC Batman : The Origin

Score: +2

Ralph Macchio

as Sal Maroni in DC Batman : The Origin

Score: +2

Mark Ruffalo

as Carmine Falcone in DC Batman : The Origin

Score: +2

Tom Felton

as Harvey Dent in DC Batman : The Origin

Score: +2

Katheryn Winnick

as Best DC Fan-casting in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Score: +79

Gina Carano

as Faora-Ul in DC Extended Universe

Score: +1

Antje Traue

as Diana Prince in DC Extended Universe

Score: -1

Chris Pine

as Benji Raynes in Evangelion

Score: +3

Hans Zimmer

as Composer in Evangelion

Score: +2

Sean Bean

as Roan Dawkins in Evangelion

Score: +3

Giancarlo Esposito

as Henry Turner in Evangelion

Score: +2

Pasha D. Lychnikoff

as Taras Lysenko in Evangelion

Score: +3

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Dutch van der Linde in Red Dead Redemption 2

Score: +218

Isabela Merced

as Traci Thirteen in DC Extended Universe

Score: +1

Monica Raymund

as Nimue Inwudu in DC Extended Universe

Score: +1

Colin Farrell

as Jason Blood in DC Extended Universe

Score: +1