Suggestions by @mercury4ever

Sam Elliott

as J. D. "Jed" Clampett in The Beverly Hillbillies

Score: +5

Jessica Lange

as Doris Adkisson in Claw

Score: +2

Paul Giamatti

as Gary Hart in Claw

Score: 0

Jack Perry

as Chris Von Erich in Claw

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Mike Von Erich in Claw

Score: -2

Channing Tatum

as Kerry Von Erich in Claw

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as David Von Erich in Claw

Score: -1

Tom Holland

as Kevin Von Erich in Claw

Score: 0

Tommy Lee Jones

as Fritz Von Erich in Claw

Score: 0

Hugh Grant

as Rez Gavron in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: +3

James Gandolfini

as Lorenzo Campana in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: +1

Martin Lawrence

as George "Noodles" Stone in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: +3

Dustin Hoffman

as Bobby Maine in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: -1

Carrie Underwood

as Ally Maine in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: +3

Luke Perry

as Jackson "Jack" Maine in A Star is Born (2005)

Score: +2

Timothy Bottoms

as Jackson Maine in A Star Is Born (1988)

Score: 0

Jack Nicholson

as Jackson Maine in A Star Is Born (1988)

Score: +1

Jon Voight

as Jackson Maine in A Star Is Born (1988)

Score: -1

Dustin Hoffman

as Jackson Maine in A Star Is Born (1988)

Score: -1

Clint Eastwood

as Jackson Maine in A Star Is Born (1988)

Score: -1