Suggestions by @mercury4ever

Evan Peters

as Underrated Actor in Underrated & Overrated Actors

Score: +25

Finn Wittrock

as Eric Bischoff in American Crime Story: Crossface

Score: 0

Mila Kunis

as Nancy Benoit in American Crime Story: Crossface

Score: +4

Michael Fassbender

as Chris Benoit in American Crime Story: Crossface

Score: +4

Alfre Woodard

as Eunice Simpson in Dirty John: Nicole

Score: +2

Charlie Plummer

as Kato Kaelin in Dirty John: Nicole

Score: +1

Shree Crooks

as Tonya Beasley in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1

Paul Giamatti

as Sheriff Stephen Hannum in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1

CJ Adams

as Brogan Rafferty in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +2

John C. Reilly

as Scott Davis in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Timothy Kern in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1

Richard Linklater

as Director in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as Ralph Geiger in Job of a Lifetime

Score: +1